PIDs


Photoionization detectors use an ultraviolet lamp to ionize a gas sample and detect its concentration. The UV lamp ionizes the sample, electrically charging it. The sensor electrodes detect and measure the current. The instrument software translates the detected current into ppm or ppb. Since PIDs ionize only a small fraction of the sample during detection, the sample can be collected from the PID outlet for further analysis. PIDs are typically zeroed in clean air, and calibrated to 100 ppm (parts per million) isobutylene.
PIDs are handheld, portable instruments. Some have belt-clips, and are suitable for personal protection monitoring against most VOCs.
The range of most PIDs is 0 to 10,000 ppm. Some PIDs, the ppbRAE plus for example, have a range of 1 ppb (parts per billion) to 4000 ppm. Readings below 10 ppm display in ppb. PIDs can detect samples in an inert sample matrix without oxygen, such as argon or nitrogen. PIDs will not detect methane, which has an ionization potential of 12.6 eV. PIDs are limited to detecting compounds with ionization energies less than 11.7 eV. They are available with lamps of varying intensities (9.8 eV, 10.6 eV, 11.7 eV) to target certain compounds. The 10.6 eV lamp is the most common.
FIDs

Flame Ionization Detectors use a hydrogen flame to ionize the sample gas and then detect its concentration. Electrons are ejected from the VOC molecules in the hydrogen flame. The electrically charged ions produce a current detected by the sensor electrodes. The FIDs converts this current to a ppm reading on the screen. FIDs are usually calibrated with 100 ppm methane, but calibration concentrations up to 25,000 ppm methane are available. Although the hydrogen flame ionization allows us to detect methane at 12.6eV, it is a destructive method. The sample is burned, preventing collection for later analysis.
FIDs are handheld, but not suitable for personal monitoring. They tend to be larger than PIDs. Since FIDs use a hydrogen flame, the internal tank needs filling after 4 – 8 hours of use.
FIDs, such as the Photovac MicroFID, will detect VOCs in reference to methane from 0 to 50,000 ppm. Oxygen is required to sustain the hydrogen flame; therefore, FIDs will not operate in an inert matrix unless introducing oxygen to the sample stream.
FID / PID combination units
The Thermo TVA-1000 PID/ FID is a combination unit, containing both a PID and FID. It is about the size of a small brief case, with a sensor handle attached to the unit with a sample hose. In situations where a sample contains methane and VOCs, the TVA-1000 will do the job by displaying a VOC only reading, since it cannot detect methane. The FID will detect methane and VOCs. If you take a FID reading with a carbon filter attached to scrub out VOCs, you will get a methane only reading.
Why do PIDs and FIDs read the same gasses differently?
While both units detect VOCs, they do it differently, PIDs with UV light, and FIDs with a hydrogen flame. PIDs are more accurate at the low scale, while FIDs have better linearity throughout their range.
PID order of sensitivity: Aromatics, iodine compounds, olefins, ketones, ethers, amines,sulfur compounds, esters, aldehydes, alcohols, aliphatics, chlorinated aliphatics, ethane, methane (no response)
FID order of sensitivity: Aromatics, long-chain compounds, short-chain compounds (methane), chlorine, bromine and iodine compounds.
PID and FID Information
• The NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards is useful in determining the IP (ionization potential) of many compounds, and ways to detect them.
• Another good resource for IPs and correction factors is RAE Systems tech note 106, Correction Factors, Ionization Energies, and Calibration Characteristics.
Contact your local Pine office for a copy of the Photovac MicroFID or Thermo TVA-1000 response factor lists.
Please call your local Pine office with any questions and thank you for choosing Pine!
Colorimeters measure light absorbed by a sample after a chemical reagent produces a color change. The intensity of absorbed light is directly proportional to the concentration of the compound, therefore colorimeters can accurately measure the concentration of various compounds in the sample. Colorimeters measure light wavelengths in the visible light range. The Hach DR 890 colorimeter has four fixed wavelengths: 420, 520, 560, and 610 nm. Hach colorimeters function with specific compound test kits for relatively quick and accurate analysis. The instruments are pre-programmedwith a variety of test methods which can reduce operator error and simplify analysis.
Spectrophotometers, sometimes referred to as UV-Vis spectrophotometers, also measure the intensity of light passing through a sample. They are used to determine the absorbance of light in a sample, ultimately allowing for the determination of color, concentration, or other pertinent information. Spectrophotometers operate using a broader wavelength range than colorimeters, including UV and visible wavelengths; 190–1100 nm. The broader spectral range increases the number of analytes detected by the instrument to almost twice as many substances as colorimeters with greater accuracy.